Jones, Denis FrancisWednesday, 22 November 1972 |
Dáil Eireann Debate
Page of 40
|
Deputy Belton, without interruption.
We are dealing with rate collectors.
It is not applicable to the Bill.
Will the Deputy please keep to the Bill before the House?
Order. Deputy Coogan on the Bill.
I hope the Deputy is.
It has nothing to do with this Bill. If the Deputy persists the Chair will ask him to resume his seat. The Deputy will keep to the Bill.
Deputy L'Estrange is not helping by interrupting.
Will the Deputy keep to the Bill?
Deputy Coogan should address the Chair on the Bill. He should not be diverted.
Deputy Hussey. Deputy L'Estrange should not attack any civil servant in the House.
No Deputy may attack civil servants in the House.
The Deputy is accusing civil servants——
The Deputy will withdraw that statement.
The Deputy will withdraw it.
The Deputy will withdraw the statement.
The Deputy will withdraw the statement.
If the Deputy will not withdraw the statement he will have to leave the House.
The Deputy made a statement and the Chair asked him to withdraw that statement, not to attack civil servants in the House.
In reply to Deputy Fitzpatrick's point, if Deputy L'Estrange or any other Deputy has a complaint like this to make there is a way of making it but then it should not be made in public. Every Deputy is...
All the Chair is pointing out to Deputy L'Estrange is that these remarks should not be made. The Chair has asked him in the ordinary way to withdraw this. There is a way in which Deputy L'Estrange c...
Everybody knows that civil servants may not rise in this House.
The Deputy should resume his seat. In the interests of order, I suggest to Deputy L'Estrange that he should withdraw his statement and that if he wishes to make a complaint he may do so in the ordina...
The Chair has no knowledge of that.
The Chair has put it to Deputy L'Estrange that in the interests of order he should withdraw this statement.
The Deputy is not leaving much option to the Chair.
Is Deputy L'Estrange withdrawing his statement about a civil servant?
Will Deputy L'Estrange now withdraw his remarks?
Interruptions are disorderly. Deputy Power.
The Minister is entitled to reply. There should be no more interruptions.
The Chair does not want any interruptions.
The Chair has repeatedly said that interruptions are disorderly.
The House deserves that a speaker should be heard without interruption.
The Minister is entitled to reply to points made.
Will the Deputy allow the Minister to conclude?
The House should allow the Minister to proceed.
The House should allow the Minister to proceed.
Tourist Traffic Bill, 1972: Second Stage.
The Deputy appreciates that this is a limited type of Bill.
The Chair thinks that we should stick to the general principles of the Bill on Second Reading.
| Last Updated: 15/09/2010 01:16:52 |
Page of 40
|